The Silent Threat: Why Employees Aren’t Reporting Cyber Incidents and How to Fix It

In today’s hyper-connected world, the digital landscape is less a serene meadow and more a treacherous minefield, isn’t it? Cyberattacks, once the stuff of Hollywood thrillers, are now an everyday reality, relentlessly hammering organizations of every conceivable size. From the sprawling multinational conglomerate to the nimble startup operating out of a co-working space, the threat looms large. You’ve seen the headlines, heard the whispers in boardrooms, the sheer audacity of these digital intrusions is frankly, astonishing. Yet, amidst this escalating peril, a deeply troubling, almost counter-intuitive, trend has emerged: a significant number of employees are actively choosing to conceal these critical incidents from their own employers. It’s like finding a small fire, but deciding to keep it a secret, hoping it just, well, puts itself out.

This isn’t merely a minor oversight; it’s a chasm, a gaping vulnerability that organizations, despite pouring resources into sophisticated security tools, often overlook. Because the most potent firewall, the most advanced AI detection system, means little if the human element – the one often on the front lines – becomes a silent accomplice to the threat. We’re talking about individuals who spot the anomalous email, click the suspicious link, or notice something just off about their system, but then, for reasons we’ll explore, bottle it up.

Dont let data threats slow you downTrueNAS offers enterprise-level protection.

The Unsettling Reluctance to Report

Recent data, stark and unflinching, paints a clear picture of this widespread reluctance. It’s not just a hunch; it’s a measurable phenomenon that should send a chill down the spine of any security professional. Take the findings from a revealing survey by Cohesity, for instance. It unveiled that a staggering 39% of UK office workers, nearly two in five, would simply not bother informing their company’s cybersecurity teams if they even suspected a cyberattack. Imagine that. A potential breach unfolding, and a substantial chunk of your workforce would rather keep it under wraps. That’s a lot of potential blind spots, isn’t it?

And it’s not for lack of awareness, which makes the situation even more perplexing. The same survey indicated a relatively high level of cybersecurity savvy among UK workers: 43% grasp the insidious nature of ransomware, and a robust 79% feel quite confident in their ability to identify a cyberattack when it comes knocking. So, they know what ransomware is, they can spot a phishing attempt, yet they’re holding back? Why? The answer, distressingly, often boils down to something deeply human: embarrassment and a primal fear of blame or punishment. It’s a psychological barrier, a wall constructed from apprehension, that significantly trumps their understanding of the looming digital danger.

Then there’s the compelling study by ThinkCyber, which echoed these anxieties, finding that over 50% of employees dread reporting cybersecurity mistakes due to the potential repercussions from their organizations. Think about it: a moment of accidental vulnerability, a misclick, and suddenly, you’re not just worried about the security incident itself, you’re worried about your job, your reputation, your next performance review. Employees, it seems, often feel profoundly underprepared to handle security risks, both technically and emotionally. This creates a dangerous feedback loop where small, unreported vulnerabilities fester, blooming into severe, costly security breaches that could have been nipped in the bud.

It makes you wonder, doesn’t it? If we’re spending billions on technology, but failing to address the fundamental human reluctance to speak up, aren’t we just patching holes in a leaky bucket with a sieve?

Dissecting the Factors Behind Underreporting

So, what drives this widespread reluctance? It’s rarely a single cause but rather a complex interplay of organizational culture, individual psychology, and practical shortcomings. Let’s pull back the curtain on some of these contributing factors; you might even recognise some in your own workplace.

The Shadow of Repercussions and Blame

This is arguably the most significant deterrent. Employees, quite naturally, worry about facing disciplinary actions, the spectre of job loss, or receiving negative performance reviews if they admit to a cybersecurity misstep. Imagine being new to a role, still finding your feet, and you accidentally open a malicious attachment. The immediate thought isn’t always ‘how do I fix this?’, it’s often ‘oh god, I’m going to get fired.’ This fear isn’t always unfounded; some organizations, sadly, possess a punitive culture where mistakes, especially those with potential financial implications, are met with heavy-handed responses rather than a focus on learning and prevention.

Consider the pressure on teams to meet targets, to deliver projects on time. A perceived blunder in cybersecurity, even an accidental one, can feel like a direct threat to that hard-earned professional standing. I recall a conversation with a friend working in a heavily regulated industry; he once recounted how a colleague accidentally leaked a non-sensitive document to the wrong internal distribution list. While the impact was negligible, the colleague faced a formal reprimand and a black mark on their record for what was clearly an honest mistake. Incidents like these, even if unrelated to cybersecurity directly, propagate an insidious message throughout the organization: ‘don’t screw up, and if you do, don’t tell anyone.’ When that becomes the unspoken rule, reporting a potential cyberattack feels like signing your own professional death warrant, even when it’s utterly vital for the company’s survival.

The Labyrinth of Unclear Procedures and Lack of Awareness

It’s not always malicious intent or even fear; sometimes, it’s simply a matter of not knowing what to do. Many employees are woefully unaware of the proper, established procedures for reporting security incidents. Is there a specific email address? A dedicated hotline? A button in a software application? Or do you just tell your boss, who then tells their boss, and so on, creating a game of corporate telephone? The process, if it even exists, can be opaque, confusing, or just plain absent. If you don’t know how to report, or who to report to, you’re less likely to do it, aren’t you?

Furthermore, beyond the mechanics of reporting, many don’t fully grasp the gravity of doing so. They might see a suspicious email as an annoyance, a personal near-miss, rather than a potential gateway for a sophisticated ransomware attack that could cripple the entire company. Regular, engaging training sessions that move beyond ticking a box on an annual compliance module are crucial here. It’s about equipping employees with the knowledge needed to not just spot threats but to genuinely understand the cascading consequences of inaction. If you truly comprehend that one unreported phishing email can lead to millions in damages and potential job losses, including your own, you’re much more likely to hit that report button.

The ‘Not My Circus’ Mentality: Misconception of Responsibility

‘That’s IT’s job, isn’t it?’ This sentiment, sadly, runs rampant in many organizations. Some employees genuinely believe that reporting a cyberattack or a suspicious event is someone else’s responsibility, perhaps the dedicated IT or security team. They might think, ‘Oh, the system will catch it,’ or ‘The security team has advanced tools, they’ll know.’ This leads to a dangerous passivity, an abdication of individual responsibility that can prove catastrophic. They essentially become bystanders rather than active participants in the company’s defence.

But here’s the thing: while IT and security teams are the specialists, they can’t be everywhere at once. They can’t see every single suspicious email landing in an individual’s inbox, or every subtle anomaly on a workstation. Employees are the eyes and ears on the ground, the very first line of defence. They interact directly with the systems and data that attackers target. When they outsource the mental burden of security to a centralised team, they inadvertently create blind spots that attackers can exploit with startling ease. It’s a bit like living in a neighbourhood and assuming the police know about every suspicious car, even if you see one idling outside your house for hours. You’d call them, wouldn’t you? The same proactive mindset is needed here.

Overconfidence and Complacency in Security Measures

Paradoxically, strong security rhetoric from management can sometimes backfire. If employees are constantly told ‘our systems are robust,’ ‘our firewalls are impenetrable,’ or ‘we’ve invested heavily in cutting-edge security,’ they might develop a false sense of security. They might trust that the company’s existing security measures are sufficient to block all phishing attempts, malware, or other threats, leading them to underestimate the critical need for reporting suspicious emails or odd system behaviour. ‘Why bother?’ they might think, ‘The system will catch it anyway.’

This overconfidence breeds complacency. It fosters an environment where vigilance erodes because the perceived threat is low, thanks to the perceived strength of the technical safeguards. While technological defences are undeniably crucial, they are never 100% foolproof. Attackers are constantly evolving, finding new vectors and exploiting human vulnerabilities. Believing that technology alone is the silver bullet is a dangerous illusion, and it often leads to employees dropping their guard, becoming less inclined to report the seemingly minor anomalies that could, in fact, be the canary in the coal mine.

The Cumbersome Reporting Process Itself

Let’s be honest, sometimes the process of doing the ‘right thing’ is just plain difficult. If reporting a cyber incident involves navigating a complex intranet portal, filling out a multi-page form, jumping through hoops, or waiting on hold for an hour, many employees will simply give up. Time is money, and in a busy work day, if the effort required to report seems disproportionate to the perceived threat, it won’t happen. A quick, intuitive, and readily accessible reporting mechanism is not a luxury; it’s a fundamental necessity.

Think about consumer apps – they strive for seamless user experience. Why should internal security tools be any different? If reporting a phishing email is as simple as clicking a dedicated ‘Report Phish’ button in their email client, they’re far more likely to do it. If it requires saving the email, drafting a new email to an obscure address, copying headers, and attaching logs, you’ve just created a barrier that few will bother to overcome. Convenience, believe it or not, plays a massive role in encouraging desired behaviours, including incident reporting. It’s an almost universally accepted truth: friction reduces adoption.

A Culture of Silence and Lack of Recognition

Finally, beyond the immediate fear of punishment, many organizations simply don’t cultivate a culture where speaking up is celebrated or even acknowledged. If employees report an incident, and then hear nothing back – no ‘thank you,’ no ‘we’re investigating,’ no ‘great catch!’ – they might feel their efforts were wasted. If the process is a black hole, people stop throwing things into it. Conversely, if employees see colleagues being praised (perhaps anonymously to protect privacy) for reporting potential threats, it creates a positive reinforcement loop. People want to feel valued, to know their actions have an impact. If reporting is met with silence, or worse, scrutiny, that desire quickly evaporates.

The Cascade: Impact on Organizations

The consequences of this underreporting phenomenon are, frankly, chilling. It’s not just about a few missed emails; it’s about opening the floodgates to potentially catastrophic damage. When employees silently endure or conceal cyber incidents, the organization essentially loses its early warning system. This delay, this lack of immediate visibility, creates a cascading effect of negative outcomes that can cripple a business.

Exacerbated Financial Costs

Let’s talk money, because that often gets management’s attention, doesn’t it? IBM data paints a stark picture: breaches lasting over 200 days are a staggering 34% more costly than those contained earlier. Think about that: a cyber incident that festers, unreported, for months, drains significantly more resources from your bottom line. These costs aren’t just direct; they balloon rapidly, encompassing everything from extensive forensic investigations to identify the breach’s scope, to costly system remediation efforts, to potential legal fees and regulatory fines. Add to that the lost productivity as systems are offline, employees are unable to work, and crucial business operations grind to a halt. The financial drain can be immense, often pushing smaller businesses to the brink of collapse.

Operational Disruption and Downtime

An unreported phishing email, if successful, could lead to a ransomware infection that encrypts critical servers, bringing operations to a standstill. Imagine your sales team unable to access customer data, your production line halting due to compromised industrial control systems, or your finance department locked out of accounting software. This isn’t just an inconvenience; it’s operational paralysis. Every minute of downtime translates directly into lost revenue, missed opportunities, and a furious customer base. And the longer an incident goes unreported, the more entrenched and pervasive the threat becomes, making recovery exponentially more difficult and time-consuming.

Irreparable Reputational Damage

Perhaps even more insidious than the financial hit is the damage to an organization’s reputation. When news of a breach leaks – and it almost always does – it erodes customer trust, diminishes investor confidence, and taints public perception. Would you willingly do business with a company known for recurrent, unchecked security breaches? Probably not, and neither would most others. Partners might reconsider collaborations, talent might shy away from joining, and regulatory bodies will scrutinize every move. Rebuilding trust is a marathon, not a sprint, and sometimes, the damage is so profound that a company never truly recovers its former standing. A brand built over decades can crumble in days due to a preventable, unreported incident.

Legal and Regulatory Repercussions

We live in an age of stringent data protection laws. GDPR in Europe, HIPAA in healthcare, CCPA in California – these aren’t just guidelines; they carry hefty penalties for non-compliance. An unreported incident that leads to a data breach could trigger massive fines, class-action lawsuits, and intense scrutiny from regulatory bodies. Companies often have a legal obligation to report breaches within a specific timeframe once discovered. If discovery is delayed because employees are keeping silent, the legal exposure dramatically increases. Ignorance, or rather, unreported knowledge, is definitely not bliss in this landscape.

Escalating Vulnerability

Small, seemingly insignificant unreported incidents can snowball into major, systemic breaches. A single compromised credential from an unreported phishing attempt might give an attacker a foothold, allowing them to patiently map out the network, escalate privileges, and eventually launch a devastating attack like a supply chain compromise or a data exfiltration campaign. Each unreported anomaly, each dismissed warning sign, creates a blind spot that attackers can exploit. It’s like leaving a tiny crack in your window; over time, that crack can become a gaping hole that lets the storm right into your living room.

Cultivating a Culture of Transparency and Trust

So, what’s the antidote to this silent epidemic? It’s not just about more technology, though that helps. It’s fundamentally about shifting the organizational paradigm, about fostering a culture where trust isn’t a buzzword but a lived reality. We need to create an environment where reporting a cyber incident feels like the safest, most logical thing to do, not the riskiest.

Establishing Crystal-Clear, Accessible Reporting Channels

First things first: make it ridiculously easy to report. Clear, uncomplicated, and widely communicated policies for incident reporting are absolutely paramount. Don’t bury the process in a dusty employee handbook; put it front and centre. This means dedicated email addresses that actually get monitored, perhaps a specific button within email clients to report suspicious messages, a prominent link on the intranet homepage, or even an anonymous reporting option for those truly gripped by fear. Employees shouldn’t have to guess or search; the path to reporting should be as obvious as the emergency exit in a theatre. You want them to think, ‘Ah, this is where I go,’ not ‘Now, who do I even tell?’

Embracing a Non-Punitive, ‘No-Blame’ Approach

This is perhaps the most critical, yet often the most challenging, shift. Organizations must commit to a non-punitive stance for honest mistakes. When an employee reports an incident, the immediate response shouldn’t be accusatory, but rather supportive: ‘Thank you for reporting this. We’ll look into it. You did the right thing.’ This means actively demonstrating that reporting errors, even those that lead to a security event, will not result in immediate disciplinary action or negative repercussions. Now, obviously, this doesn’t apply to malicious intent or gross negligence, but for genuine human error – which is often at the heart of many initial compromises – a blameless post-mortem approach is far more effective. Focus on understanding why the mistake happened, improving processes, and bolstering defences, rather than simply pointing fingers. When people feel safe, they open up, and that transparency is gold.

Continuous, Engaging Security Awareness Training

One-off, annual compliance training sessions are simply not enough. We need ongoing, dynamic, and engaging education that goes beyond dry presentations. Think micro-learning modules, simulated phishing exercises that provide immediate feedback, gamified challenges, and real-world case studies tailored to your industry. Employees need to learn not just what a threat looks like, but why it matters to them personally and professionally, and how their swift action can avert disaster. Regular training reinforces the importance of vigilance and equips employees with the knowledge needed to confidently spot and address cyber threats. It’s about building a security mindset, not just checking a box. If you can make it fun, or at least interesting, people will retain it better, won’t they?

Leadership Leading by Example

Security isn’t just an IT problem; it’s a business imperative, and leadership must embody this understanding. Management, from the CEO down, should visibly demonstrate a vested interest in the organization’s cyber posture. This means participating in training, publicly acknowledging the importance of reporting, and standing shoulder-to-shoulder with their IT and security teams. When leaders openly champion cybersecurity, provide the necessary resources, and ensure support is available for reporting and responding to attacks, it sends a powerful message throughout the entire company. Employees see that management cares, that they are invested in this, and that their efforts to report are genuinely valued. When the boss talks about it, people listen.

Positive Reinforcement and Recognition

Beyond just avoiding punishment, actively reward and acknowledge employees who report incidents. This doesn’t necessarily mean monetary bonuses, though that can help. A simple public ‘shout-out’ in a team meeting, an email from a senior leader, or a mention in the company newsletter for ‘Outstanding Vigilance’ can go a long way. Small acts of recognition reinforce the desired behaviour and motivate others to follow suit. It transforms reporting from a potentially risky chore into a recognized contribution to collective security.

Fostering an Environment of Open Dialogue

Ultimately, creating a truly secure environment hinges on open dialogue. Encourage employees to ask questions about cybersecurity, to express concerns, and to suggest improvements. Create forums, virtual or in-person, where security teams can share insights, educate, and listen to feedback from the front lines. When employees feel heard, when they believe their input is valued, they become active participants in the security ecosystem rather than passive recipients of mandates. It’s about building a genuine partnership between every individual and the security team, fostering a shared sense of responsibility for protecting the collective digital estate. Because, frankly, a company is only as secure as its least secure, and most apprehensive, employee.

In conclusion, while the raw, primal fear of repercussions certainly stands as a formidable barrier to reporting cyberattacks, organizations aren’t helpless in the face of it. By actively dismantling that fear, by creating a supportive, transparent environment that genuinely encourages openness and proactive communication, companies can fundamentally transform their cybersecurity posture. It’s an investment not just in technology, but in people, in trust, and in building a resilient, human-centric defence against the ever-evolving, increasingly sophisticated threat landscape. And frankly, in this digital age, can you really afford not to? It’s not just good practice, it’s essential for survival.

---

References

• Cohesity Survey Reveals 39% of UK Workers Wouldn’t Report Cyberattacks
• ThinkCyber Study Finds Over 50% of Employees Fear Reporting Cybersecurity Mistakes
• IBM Data Shows Breaches Lasting Over 200 Days Are 34% More Costly
• Cleartech Group Discusses the Critical Issue of Cybersecurity and Employee Reporting
• itusprotect.io Blog on Employee Cyber Incident Reporting
• securitymagazine.com Article on Guilt of Not Reporting Cyber Attack to Leadership
• xentricsolutions.com Blog on Employees Not Reporting Security Issues
• anz.peoplemattersglobal.com Article on Employees’ Fear of Reporting Mistakes